plusonepizza.comPlus 1 Pizza | Award Winning Local Pizza For Over 40 Years

Pintrest Code Youtube Verify Google Ad Remarketing Tag Google Optimize Code Order Online  Athens Ohio Cambridge Ohio Byesville Ohio Coshocton Ohio Caldwell Ohio Menu Athens Cambridge Byesville Coshocton Caldwell Specials Rewards Club Athens Cambridge Byesville Coshocton Caldwell Contact Us Athens Cambridge Byesville Coshocton Caldwell Our Pizza Home Order Athens Cambridge Byesville Coshocton Caldwell Find Us Athens Cambridge Byesville Coshocton Caldwell Locations Athens Cambridge Byesville Coshocton Caldwell Tracker About Us Fresh Exceptional Ingredients for Outstanding Pizza! Where people who love pizza never settle for anything less than homemade dough, real Wisconsin cheese and loads of the world's best toppings. You in? Order Online Athens Cambridge Byesville Coshocton CAldwell Full Menu Athens Cambridge Byesville Coshocton Caldwell Specials Athens Cambridge Byesville Coshocton Caldwell Call Us Athens Cambridge Byesville Coshocton Caldwell Find Us Athens Cambridge Byesville Coshocton Caldwell Fresh Exceptional Ingredients for Outstanding Pizza Where people who love pizza never settle for anything less than homemade dough, real Wisconsin cheese, and loads of the world's best toppings. You in?  Need a Job?  Join Our Team and Help Us Make Smiles, Apply online. Click Here to Learn More Best Pizza - Awards Check out our bling! Family & Locally Owned Pizzeria Over 50 Toppings Topping Dictionary Never Settle for Corporate Pizza Gluten Free! New Gluten Free Tater Tots for your pizza - It Rocks! Check Out What's New! New Totza Pizza Hits the menu - Tater Tots our a big hit with fans Read Post > New Mega Cookies New Cookies now on the menu Check out the menu Read Post > Cowboy BBQ Chicken Smoked Gouda Cheese & Fresh Cilantro Add these new toppings to any pizza Read Post > Customer Service Athens Cambridge Byesville Coshocton Caldwell Rewards Club About Us Our Pizza Employment Enjoy Life, Have Fun... Eat Better Pizza Athens 740-594-9494       Cambridge 740-439-1333      Byesville  740-685-1999      Coshocton  740-622-9300    Caldwell  740-732-551 Local Pizza Delivery  Place and Restaurant with Shops in Athens, Cambridge, Byesville, Coshocton and Caldwell Ohio Looking for a local pizza delivery place and family pizza restaurant – then welcome to  Plus 1 Pizza.    We are a locally owned and family operated pizza shop and restaurant with dine-in, carry-out and pizza delivery service. Order a fresh pizza, pasta, sub sandwiches, stromboli, wings and salads. About us and our family We are a small,  family owned and operated pizza parlor that specializes in creating totally fresh  signature pizzas. Take a look at your thumbprint. Did you know that no one in the entire world has a thumbprint just like yours?  With over 50 toppings, 10 sauces, and several cheeses to choose from that you can create an unique pizza that is one of a kind just like you?  Oh, and I almost forgot to mention that our dough is freshly made each and every day!  We don't take short-cuts like other places. We never use frozen dough nor frozen cheeses.  We take great pride in our family  to buy and use only the best and freshest ingredients that that money can buy. We are passionate about pizza and love what we do.  All this attention to detail and specialization come from three generations of pizza operators.  So we invite you to come visit us and try a fresh unique (just like you) pizza or have it delivered with our local fast pizza delivery team. Photo: Cole Fettes, Bob Fettes Jr, and Bob Fettes Sr, retired. Our Ingredients – Fresh dough – 100% real premium cheese  both mozzarella and provolone – Fresh cut veggies – Homemade sauce prepared fresh daily with vine-ripened tomatoes – 100% real pepperoni and premium meat toppings Prepared to Order Whether creating your own pizza, from an incredible choice of over 50 toppings, or choosing one of our 24 signature specialty pizzas, every order is prepared only after it is ordered! It takes a bit longer but is well-worth the wait. Fresh Made Dough Every great pizza starts with a great crust! Our incredible, out-of-this-world crust is made with our signature, homemade dough recipes, prepared in multiple batches throughout the day. Our dough is always fresh Great Service Service with a smile. We love our customers and want you to be happy. Our mission: to delight every customer one pizza at a time. If your not delighted let us know and we’ll make it right.  Who Are We? We are a small family owned and operated pizzeria. We make fresh handcrafted pizza that people connect over. That’s our thing. We know we’re not creating world peace treaties,  but we take our job seriously. We live by a set of core values each and every day. We have fun. We love what we do and we want everyone to know what we’re about. Our Mission Statement: To delight every customer one pizza at a time and to be the best pizzeria in the world by killing it on every detail of the customer experience. Our Core Values – Have fun – Do it with passion – Build something special – Give back to the community – Give customers what they want – Source only the best and freshest ingredients Never settle for pizza made by the Man! Buy Fresh, Buy Local Don’t settle and order from the a one of those big corporate chain pizza places in town. All the big guys prepare their pizza with one thing in mind, shareholder profits. From frozen dough, meat fillers and poor customer service, their pizza is not inspiring, original or local.  Don’t buy pizza made by the man.  Just say no to corporate pizza. Why not enjoy life, have fun and eat better pizza.  Go for a unique mouthwatering pizza that is prepared with only the highest quality and freshest ingredients. Why not go for a pizza that is prepared with only you and your taste-buds in mind. That’s what we do. We source only the freshest and best ingredients we can find and create custom handcraft pizzas with fresh quality ingredients in every pizza. Tell us your favorite crust, sauce, and toppings. We’ll create you a pizza that fits your personality and that is as unique as you. Pick Your Crust,  Sauce,  Cheese, Favorite Toppings,  Crust Topper, and a Topping Drizzle Crust ORIGINAL CLASSIC CRUST An original, classic medium-thick crust, light and airy with a home-baked flavor. THIN CRUST  Crispy thin crust that bakes to a golden brown with a extra crispy texture.  Our thin crust lets full flavor form the cheese and toppings hit your taste buds.  COMING SOON -DEEP DISH Thicker crust with a pleasing crunch on the outside, soft and tender on the inside. GLUTEN FREE     Gluten Free** Medium size only Sauce FAMILY RECIPE SIGNATURE PIZZA SAUCE Our original family recipe. Our signature naturally sweet red tomato sauce that's made fresh daily in a Plus One Pizza tradition. NEAPOLITAN PIZZA SAUCE Red tomato sauce packed with more garlic and oregano for customers that like a little more garlic. FRESH GARLIC SAUCE Minced-from-the-clove garlic with extra virgin olive oil for just the right flavor. Made for true garlic lovers. GARLIC HERB SAUCE Butter garlic sauce with blend of Italian seasoning and herbs. TUSCAN PIZZA SAUCE A savory combination of our signature red sauce and buttery garlic sauce. BARBECUE SAUCE   Sweet Ray's barbecue sauce ALFREDO SAUCE Cream, butter, parmesan cheese & chopped garlic PESTO SAUCE Pesto-Basil sauceRANCH SAUCECreamy ranch sauce Toppings Our family has delighted our guests through our passion for pizza.  We are constantly searching for ingredients of the highest quality to create one-of-a-kind flavor combinations that keep folks coming back for more. MEATS & MORE Pepperoni  -  Old World Pepperoni - Spicy Pepperoni - Bacon - Sausage -  Ground Beef - Ham - Chicken* - Italian Sausage - Anchovies VEGGIES & CHEESES Roma Tomatoes -  Mushrooms - ...